QuickBooks vs Xero: Which Accounting Software Is Better for Small Business?

“Should I use QuickBooks or Xero?”

As a bookkeeper, I get this question constantly. Both are excellent cloud accounting platforms. Both can handle most small business needs. But they’re not identical, and the right choice depends on your specific situation.

This is an honest, practical comparison to help you decide.

The Quick Answer

Choose QuickBooks Online if:

• You’re in the US and want maximum accountant compatibility
• You need robust payroll integration
• Your industry has QuickBooks-specific integrations
• You value a large support ecosystem

Choose Xero if:

• You want unlimited users at no extra cost
• You prefer a cleaner, more modern interface
• You work with international currencies regularly
• You want simpler bank reconciliation

Now let’s dig into the details.

Feature Comparison

Core Accounting

Feature	QuickBooks Online	Xero
Bank connections	Excellent	Excellent
Bank reconciliation	Standard approach	More streamlined
Invoicing	Strong	Strong
Bill pay	Good	Good
Multi-currency	Available (higher tiers)	Built-in
Inventory	Good	Basic
Projects/Job costing	Good	Limited

Winner: Tie for basic accounting. QuickBooks edges ahead for inventory and projects.

User Experience

QuickBooks Online:

• Familiar if you’ve used desktop versions
• Feature-rich but can feel cluttered
• Navigation is comprehensive but complex
• Mobile app is functional

Xero:

• Modern, clean interface
• Easier to learn
• Intuitive navigation
• Excellent mobile app

Winner: Xero for user experience and interface design.

Pricing

QuickBooks Online (2026 pricing):

• Simple Start: ~$30/month (1 user)
• Essentials: ~$60/month (3 users)
• Plus: ~$90/month (5 users)
• Advanced: ~$200/month (25 users)

Xero (2026 pricing):

• Starter: ~$15/month (limited invoices/bills)
• Standard: ~$42/month (unlimited)
• Premium: ~$78/month (multi-currency)
• All plans include unlimited users

Winner: Xero for value, especially if you need multiple users.

Payroll

QuickBooks Online:

• Integrated payroll is excellent
• Full-service options available
• Seamless with accounting
• Well-established in US market

Xero:

• Relies on third-party integrations (Gusto, etc.)
• Integration quality varies
• May require separate subscriptions
• More steps in workflow

Winner: QuickBooks for US payroll integration.

Reporting

QuickBooks Online:

• Extensive built-in reports
• More customization options
• Familiar layouts for accountants
• Strong filtering and date range controls

Xero:

• Clean, readable reports
• Good standard reports
• Less customization
• Solid for most needs

Winner: QuickBooks for reporting depth and customization.

Integrations

QuickBooks Online:

• Largest app ecosystem in US
• More industry-specific solutions
• Strong payment integrations
• Better point-of-sale options

Xero:

• Strong ecosystem globally
• Growing US integrations
• Excellent inventory/e-commerce connections
• Good for international businesses

Winner: QuickBooks for US integrations; Xero for international.

Bank Reconciliation

QuickBooks Online:

• Traditional matching approach
• Manual matching of transactions
• Bulk categorization available
• Works well but more clicks

Xero:

• Streamlined “bank rules” system
• More automated matching
• Faster daily reconciliation
• Learning system improves over time

Winner: Xero for day-to-day reconciliation efficiency.

Best Use Cases

QuickBooks is Better For

Product-based businesses: QuickBooks has stronger inventory management, including tracking by location and assembly items.

Construction and job costing: Project tracking and job costing features are more developed in QuickBooks.

Businesses with complex payroll: The integrated payroll solution is more robust and seamless.

Businesses needing US accountant compatibility: Most US accountants work with QuickBooks; some don’t know Xero.

Businesses needing extensive reporting: More report options and customization for data analysis.

Xero is Better For

Businesses with multiple team members: Unlimited users means everyone can have access without incremental costs.

International businesses: Multi-currency handling is built in and more intuitive.

Businesses wanting simplicity: The interface is cleaner and easier for non-accountants.

Businesses doing high-volume reconciliation: Bank rules and matching are faster.

Businesses wanting modern design: Xero’s interface is more contemporary and pleasant to use.

Migration Considerations

Moving to QuickBooks

From Xero:

• Direct migration tools available
• Historical data transfers reasonably well
• Some manual cleanup typically needed
• Plan 2-4 hours for a small business

From spreadsheets or nothing:

• Import tools for customers, vendors, chart of accounts
• Opening balances need manual entry
• Start fresh or import history (fresh is often easier)

Moving to Xero

From QuickBooks:

• Xero has import tools for QBO data
• Conversion can be straightforward
• Some data may need manual adjustment
• Historical transactions migrate with some limitations

From spreadsheets or nothing:

• Similar to QuickBooks process
• Good import templates available
• Opening balances require attention

General Migration Advice

1. Do it at month or year end: Clean break point
2. Keep old system accessible: For reference
3. Allow time for parallel running: Verify accuracy
4. Consider professional help: For complex situations

What Accountants Say

Most US accountants prefer QuickBooks because:

• They’ve used it longer
• More clients use it
• Training investments already made
• Better support resources

However, accountants who work with Xero generally like:

• The bank reconciliation workflow
• The interface for clients
• The unlimited user model
• The growing feature set

Practical advice: Ask your accountant what they prefer, but don’t let that be the only factor. You use the software daily; they use it occasionally.

What to Consider for Your Decision

How Tech-Savvy Are You?

• Comfortable with technology: Either works
• Less comfortable: Xero’s simpler interface may help
• Want lots of features: QuickBooks has more depth

How Many People Need Access?

• Just you: Either works
• 2-3 people: QuickBooks Essentials or Xero
• 5+ people: Xero’s unlimited users is better value

Do You Need Payroll?

• Yes, in US: QuickBooks has the edge
• Yes, outside US: Research local options for both
• No: Either works equally

Do You Have Inventory?

• Significant inventory: QuickBooks has better features
• Minimal inventory: Either works
• No inventory: Either works

International Business?

• US-only: QuickBooks slightly preferred
• Multi-country: Xero handles this better
• Lots of currencies: Xero

Your Industry?

• Construction: QuickBooks
• Professional services: Either
• E-commerce: Either (check integrations)
• Manufacturing: QuickBooks
• Retail: QuickBooks (better POS options)

Making the Switch

If you’re currently on one and considering the other:

Valid reasons to switch:

• Need features the other has
• Cost savings with multiple users (to Xero)
• Accountant strongly prefers one
• Integration needs changed
• Frustration with current platform

Not great reasons to switch:

• Someone told you the other is “better”
• Grass-is-greener thinking
• Minor irritations that exist in both

The switching cost includes:

• Time for migration
• Learning curve
• Potential data issues
• New workflows to establish

If your current system is working, the switching cost may not be worth it.

The Bottom Line

Both QuickBooks Online and Xero are solid choices for small business accounting. The differences matter, but they’re not make-or-break for most businesses.

My recommendation:

1. If starting fresh: Try both free trials. See which feels more intuitive to you.

2. If your accountant strongly prefers one: That’s worth considering, but not decisive.

3. If you need specific features: Choose based on those needs.

4. If cost matters significantly: Xero’s unlimited users provides better value for teams.

5. If already using one and it works: Stay unless you have compelling reasons to switch.

Either platform, properly set up and consistently used, will serve your small business well. The bigger factor is actually using it—recording transactions, reconciling regularly, and reviewing reports.

---

Need help setting up or optimizing your accounting software? At Profit Path Books, we work with both QuickBooks and Xero. We’ll help you choose the right platform and set it up for your specific business needs. Book a consultation to discuss your situation.